How to Stand Out When Everyone Looks the Same: A No-BS Guide to Differentiation

You're in another sales call.

The prospect seems engaged. They're nodding along as you explain your product's features. Then comes that gut-punch phrase: "You sound a lot like [insert competitor]."

And just like that, you're lumped into the sea of sameness—fighting for attention in a market where everyone claims to be "innovative," "customer-centric," and "industry-leading."

I recently received an email from Michael, a reader who's living this exact nightmare. His SaaS company offers solid project management solutions, but they're drowning in the noise of bigger, flashier competitors. They've tried tweaking marketing, adjusting pricing, and adding features—but nothing's moved the needle.

Sound familiar? I thought so.

Let me share Michael's full message, and then we'll dive into how to solve this all-too-common problem:

The Letter

Struggling to Stand Out in a Crowded Market – Need Your Expertise

Dear Marco,

I've been an avid reader of your blog for a while now, and I really appreciate the no-nonsense approach you take to business strategy. So, I figured it was time to reach out and ask for help with a challenge that's been keeping me up at night.

I run a mid-sized SaaS company that provides project management solutions for professional services firms. We've built a solid product, and our customer retention is strong, but here's the problem: we're getting lost in the noise. The market is flooded with competitors—many of them bigger, flashier, and with deeper pockets.

When we pitch to prospects, we often hear things like, "You sound a lot like [insert big-name competitor here]." And honestly? They're not wrong. We don't have a clear, compelling answer to what makes us different. Our messaging feels generic, and our sales team struggles to articulate why someone should choose us over the competition.

We've tried tweaking our marketing, adjusting pricing, and adding new features, but none of it has moved the needle in a meaningful way. I worry that we're not just missing a strong differentiator—we're missing the differentiator that will actually make us stand out and win more deals.

I know you've worked with companies in similar situations before. Where do we start? How do we uncover our true competitive edge and position ourselves in a way that makes prospects take notice? Any insights you can share would be invaluable.

Looking forward to your thoughts!

Best, Michael Thompson

Why Most Differentiation Advice Is Complete Garbage

Here's what typical consultants will tell you:

"Find your USP!"
"Identify your competitive advantage!"
"Leverage your core competencies!"

Pure buzzword BS that leaves you exactly where you started.

The truth? Most companies don't have a differentiation problem. They have a courage problem.

I discovered this the hard way while working with a cybersecurity firm that was getting crushed by bigger competitors. Their product was solid—maybe even superior in some ways—but they sounded exactly like everyone else in their market.

"We need to improve our messaging," the CEO insisted as we sat in their glass-walled conference room.

I shook my head. "Your messaging isn't the problem. Your unwillingness to commit to who you actually are is the problem."

He looked at me like I'd just insulted his firstborn child.

But six months later, after implementing the strategy I'm about to share with you, their sales pipeline had doubled. They weren't trying to be all things to all people anymore. They were boldly, unapologetically themselves—and the market responded.

Stop Trying to Find Your Differentiator (Start Creating It Instead)

Most companies approach differentiation backward. They look at their existing offerings, try to spot something unique, then amplify it in their messaging.

This rarely works because:

• True technical differentiators are increasingly rare
• Features can be copied
• Customers often can't tell the difference anyway

Instead, successful companies create differentiation through strategic choices about who they serve, how they serve them, and—most importantly—who they don't serve.

Here's how you transform from generic option to category of one:

Step 1: Narrow Your Focus Until It Hurts (Then Narrow It More)

"But Marco, we can't afford to turn away customers!"

Yes, you can. And you must.

When I worked with a struggling HR software provider, their first instinct was to broaden their appeal. "We serve companies of all sizes across all industries!" they proudly declared.

Translation: "We serve no one particularly well."

We slashed their target market by 80%, focusing exclusively on manufacturing companies with 100-500 employees. Their sales team initially panicked—until deal close rates jumped from 12% to 37% in the first quarter.

Action Steps:

• List your most profitable, longest-tenured customers
• Identify common characteristics (industry, size, business model)
• Ruthlessly eliminate segments where you don't have proven success
• Redefine your target market as specifically as possible

Remember: If your target market definition doesn't make you at least a little uncomfortable with its narrowness, it's still too broad.

Step 2: Own a Problem No One Else Is Solving

Markets don't care about your features. They care about their problems.

The mistake Michael's company is making—like so many others—is focusing on what their product does rather than the specific problem it solves better than anyone else.

I once asked the leadership team at a logistics software company to list their top competitors' primary focus areas. Then I asked them to list the top 10 pain points their customers experienced. The magic happened when we overlaid these lists.

We discovered three significant customer problems that none of their competitors were directly addressing—despite having the technical capability to do so. The company repositioned entirely around one of these problems, and within a year, they were no longer seen as a "me too" solution.

Action Steps:

• Interview your best customers about their biggest challenges
• Create a comprehensive map of competitor positioning
• Identify high-value problems that are underserved
• Rebuild your entire go-to-market strategy around solving that specific problem

Step 3: Create a Methodology Only You Own

Want to stand out instantly? Name your approach.

I'm not talking about slapping a trademark symbol on your generic process. I'm talking about developing a distinctive methodology that encapsulates your unique approach to solving your customers' problems.

When I worked with a sales enablement platform that was struggling to differentiate, we developed what we called the "Revenue Acceleration Framework™." This wasn't just marketing fluff—it was a comprehensive, step-by-step methodology that delivered consistent results.

Soon, prospects weren't asking "how are you different from Competitor X?" They were asking "can you tell me more about this Revenue Acceleration Framework I've been hearing about?"

Action Steps:

• Document your approach to solving customer problems
• Identify what makes your process distinctive
• Formalize and name this methodology
• Create supporting materials that explain the philosophy behind it
• Train your sales team to lead with the methodology, not features

Step 4: Take a Stand (And Prepare for Blowback)

The companies that truly stand out aren't afraid to challenge industry orthodoxy.

When I helped a financial services firm reposition themselves, we made the bold choice to openly criticize a practice that most competitors considered standard. This wasn't manufactured controversy—the leadership team genuinely believed the conventional approach was harmful to clients.

The response was immediate. Competitors attacked. Industry publications questioned their stance. But prospects who had been frustrated by the status quo suddenly had a champion. Sales conversations transformed from tedious feature comparisons to energizing discussions about a better way forward.

Action Steps:

• Identify conventional wisdom in your industry that deserves challenging
• Articulate a strong point of view on why the status quo is failing customers
• Develop content that makes the case for your alternative approach
• Prepare your team for pushback (it means you're onto something)

Step 5: Change the Conversation Entirely

Sometimes the most powerful differentiation comes from refusing to compete on the standard terms of engagement.

I worked with a professional services firm that was constantly being compared to larger competitors with more comprehensive offerings. Rather than trying to match these competitors feature-for-feature, we changed the conversation.

Instead of responding to RFPs that asked them to check the same boxes as everyone else, they created their own assessment process that prospects had to complete before engaging. This "diagnostic-first" approach immediately set them apart and allowed them to reframe the buying process around their strengths.

Action Steps:

• Identify how buying decisions are typically made in your industry
• Determine how this conventional process disadvantages you
• Design an alternative approach that plays to your strengths
• Have the courage to walk away from opportunities that force you back into the comparison game

The Real Reason You Haven't Differentiated Yet (And How to Fix It)

I can already hear what some of you are thinking: "These all sound great in theory, Marco, but my situation is different."

No, it's not.

The real barrier to meaningful differentiation isn't lack of opportunity—it's fear. Fear of limiting your market. Fear of alienating potential customers. Fear of being wrong.

I've seen this fear paralyze otherwise brilliant leadership teams. They nod along with differentiation strategies in the boardroom, then water them down until they're meaningless.

Two years ago, I walked away from a client—a well-funded tech company—because after three strategy sessions, they refused to make the hard choices necessary for true differentiation. "We can't say that," the CMO would protest. "What if someone who doesn't fit this profile wants to buy from us?"

Six months later, they were acquired by a competitor—at a valuation far below what they'd hoped for. Their failure to stand for something specific made them just another feature set to be absorbed.

The harsh truth is this: If you're trying to appeal to everyone, you'll fascinate no one.

From Generic to Magnetic: A Personal Story

I didn't always practice what I preach. Early in my career as a consultant, I positioned myself as broadly as possible. "I help companies grow," I'd say, delivering the line with all the distinctiveness of a beige wall in a beige room.

Unsurprisingly, I was seen as interchangeable with dozens of other consultants. Prospects would ghost me after initial conversations. Projects would go to competitors. I was the human equivalent of the problem Michael's company is facing.

One night, sitting alone in an airport bar after losing a deal I thought was certain, I realized I couldn't continue this way. My generic positioning wasn't just hurting my business—it was crushing my spirit.

I took out a notebook and wrote down everything I actually believed about my industry. Not what I thought clients wanted to hear. Not what sounded safe. What I genuinely believed to be true, based on my experience.

Some of these beliefs were controversial. Some directly contradicted conventional wisdom. All of them reflected my authentic perspective.

The next day, I rewrote my entire service offering around these beliefs. I narrowed my focus to a specific industry segment where I had the strongest track record. I developed and named a methodology that embodied my distinctive approach.

Within three months, my business was unrecognizable. Prospects were reaching out based on referrals. Sales cycles shortened dramatically. Most importantly, I was working with clients who valued exactly what made my approach different.

The lesson was clear: Differentiation isn't just a marketing strategy. It's about having the courage to be who you actually are.

Your Roadmap to Remarkable Differentiation

For Michael and anyone facing the "we sound like everyone else" problem, here's your action plan:

1. This Week: Conduct customer interviews focused exclusively on understanding what they see as different about working with you. Don't prompt or lead them—just listen.
2. Next Week: Gather your leadership team and ruthlessly narrow your target market definition until it makes everyone uncomfortable.
3. Within 30 Days: Identify the primary problem you solve better than anyone else and reorient all messaging around this focus.
4. Within 60 Days: Develop and name your distinctive methodology for solving this problem.
5. Within 90 Days: Take a public stand on an industry issue that matters to your best customers, even if it means alienating some prospects.

The companies that thrive in crowded markets aren't those with marginally better features or slightly lower prices. They're the ones that have the clarity to know exactly who they are and the courage to act accordingly.

So, Michael, the choice is yours: Continue shouting into the void of sameness, or stand for something specific and watch the right customers find their way to you.

What's it going to be?

About the Author

Marco Giunta works with private equity as an operating partner managing a portfolio of companies. With over 30 years in the trenches of B2B sales and go-to-market strategy, he's helped dozens of companies—just like Michael's—break through the noise and establish clear market differentiation. Marco specializes in transforming "me too" businesses into category leaders by focusing relentlessly on the problems that matter most to customers. When he's not helping clients solve their toughest challenges, you can find him discussing the finer points of espresso preparation or analyzing the latest F1 race strategies. If you're facing challenges similar to those discussed in this article, you can reach out to Marco directly through his website at https://marcogiunta.com.

‍